setting TCLIBC = "glibc" in local.conf for linux flavour makes no effect on Goofy

The module affected

generated sdcard image

What is the action to reproduce the bug?

Put in local.conf or custom layer.conf: TCLIBC = "glibc"

What is the result you see?

musl image is created; in case of usage 3rd party library with glibc - build of image fails

What is the result you expect?

After setting TCLIBC as "glibc" proper image is build

Frequency?

always

Tested version

All oniro Goofy images on raspberrypi4-64

Do you know any workaround of this issue?

In oniro/meta-oniro-core/conf/distro/oniro-linux.conf replace TCLIBC = "musl" with TCLIBC ?= "musl"

Do you have a fix for this issue?

NO

https://gitlab.eclipse.org/eclipse-wg/oniro-wg/roadmap-oniro-wg/wishlist-roadmap/wishlist-repo/-/issues/9

IIRC I used this: https://booting.oniroproject.org/rzr/meta-oniro-blueprint-flutter/-/commit/32a43748227409b82185747804f17b613b6454f7

Any idea when this regression occurred ?

Have no idea when. On dunfell setting TCLIBC in local.conf / layer.conf was working as expected.

I think this was forced by @agherzan as workaround try my above lines to see if it unblocks you.

Unblock by fixing to musl? Not sure...

assigned to @landgraf

added Doing IssueBug labels

added teammaintenance label

Patch sent upsteam. Once accepted kiskstone backport and downstream patch will be needed

Ok feel free to link related issue, I'll check my side too

Patch merged upstream. waiting for kirkstone https://git.openembedded.org/openembedded-core/commit/?id=de6c3f9cb2c589aecbf8d9d25fa83cd18bf80891

added 1 deleted label

added SeverityCritical label

removed SeverityCritical label

added SeverityNormal label

removed SeverityNormal label

added SeverityMinor label

Ok I confirm this problem on current oniroproject/meta-openembedded 5357c7a40

Is there any pending action to get @landgraf 's patch:

https://git.openembedded.org/openembedded-core/commit/?id=de6c3f9cb2c589aecbf8d9d25fa83cd18bf80891

merged into :

https://git.openembedded.org/openembedded-core/log/?h=kirkstone

It's not there yet or can/should we apply it downstream ?

@pcoval all actions which were needed from our side has been taken already.

changed milestone to %goofy beta

changed iteration to Oniro Core Iterations Jun 1, 2022 - Jun 30, 2022

added to epic &144 (closed)

marked this issue as related to #632 (closed)

mentioned in issue #634 (closed)

changed epic to &126

marked this issue as related to #634 (closed)

marked this issue as related to #633 (closed)

removed the relation with #633 (closed)

Please @asmolniktmi confirm this is not blocking anymore, It wasnt for me with the distro's config I linked above

mentioned in merge request !150 (merged)

mentioned in merge request !151 (merged)

closed with merge request !151 (merged)

closed with commit f78cc866

added ValidationReady label

marked this issue as related to #633 (closed)

removed Doing label

@landgraf to test the issue do I have to put TCLIBC = "glibc" in oniro/meta-oniro-core/conf/distro/oniro-linux.conf? Or somewhere else?

TCLIBC="glibc" bitbake oniro-image-base should build the image with glibc, default is musl

in the build configuration log is there any information about this library?

there're few ways. The easiest way would be:

Without the fix:

pavel@gentoo /mnt/builds/oniroproject/goofy/builds/build-tclibc $ bitbake -e oniro-image-base  | grep '^TCLIBC='
TCLIBC="musl"

pavel@gentoo /mnt/builds/oniroproject/goofy/builds/build-tclibc $ TCLIBC=glibc bitbake -e oniro-image-base  | grep '^TCLIBC='
TCLIBC="musl"

With the fix:

pavel@gentoo /mnt/builds/oniroproject/goofy/builds/build-tclibc $ bitbake -e oniro-image-base  | grep '^TCLIBC='
TCLIBC="musl"

pavel@gentoo /mnt/builds/oniroproject/goofy/builds/build-tclibc $ TCLIBC=glibc bitbake -e oniro-image-base  | grep '^TCLIBC='
TCLIBC="glibc"

added ValidationPassed label and removed ValidationReady label